Posts

What Stand-Up Comedians Know About Creative Problem Solving That Your Business Team Doesn't

Three months ago, I'm sitting in a dingy comedy club in Fitzroy watching this bloke absolutely bomb on stage. I mean, proper train wreck stuff. His first joke fell flat, the second one got crickets, and by the third attempt, someone actually walked out. But here's the thing - instead of panicking or sticking to his script, he looked at the audience and said, "Well, this is going about as well as my last performance review."

The room erupted.

That moment taught me more about creative problem solving than any corporate workshop I've ever sat through, and trust me, I've sat through plenty.

The Comedy Club Connection Nobody Talks About

After 18 years in business consulting, I've noticed something peculiar. The most innovative solutions in boardrooms don't come from the MBAs with their frameworks and flowcharts. They come from people who think like comedians. People who can look at a complete disaster and find the unexpected angle that turns everything around.

Stand-up comedy is essentially rapid-fire creative problem solving under pressure. Every audience is different, every room has its own energy, and comedians have about 3.2 seconds to figure out if their material is working before they need to pivot. Sound familiar? That's every client meeting I've ever been in.

The difference is comedians embrace the chaos. Business professionals try to control it.

Why Your Innovation Sessions Are Actually Killing Innovation

I've facilitated more brainstorming sessions than I care to count, and most of them follow the same predictable pattern. Someone draws a mind map on a whiteboard, everyone nods politely, and we end up with the same three solutions we could've thought of before we walked into the room.

The problem isn't that people aren't creative. The problem is we've created environments that punish the kind of thinking that actually breeds innovation.

Comedians understand something fundamental about creativity: you have to be willing to fail spectacularly in public. Every time a comedian tries new material, they're essentially running a problem-solving experiment in real-time with immediate feedback. When businesses try to innovate, they want guarantees first.

You can't have both.

The Rule of Seven Bad Ideas

Here's something I learned from a comedian mate of mine in Adelaide: for every good joke that makes it into his set, he's written at least seven terrible ones. Not mediocre ones. Properly awful ones that would clear a room faster than a fire alarm.

Most business teams stop at idea number two.

I started implementing what I call the "Rule of Seven Bad Ideas" with my clients. Before we discuss any solution, everyone has to contribute seven genuinely bad ideas first. Not safe-bad ideas that are actually quite sensible. Properly terrible ideas that would get you laughed out of the room.

The results have been remarkable. Once people get the terrible ideas out of their system, the eighth, ninth, and tenth ideas start getting interesting. By idea fifteen, we're usually onto something revolutionary.

The Art of Reading the Room (And Why Consultants Get This Wrong)

Comedians are masters at reading their audience. They can tell within seconds whether their material is landing, and they adjust accordingly. They notice everything - the age demographic, the energy level, whether people are checking their phones, if couples are arguing in the back row.

Business consultants, on the other hand, often come in with predetermined solutions and try to force them to fit regardless of the organisational culture they're walking into.

I learned this the hard way with a manufacturing client in Wollongong about five years ago. Beautiful process improvement plan. Looked fantastic on paper. Would've saved them hundreds of thousands annually. Completely ignored the fact that their workforce had been burned by three previous "improvement initiatives" and weren't buying what anyone in a suit was selling.

A comedian would've picked up on that hostility immediately and changed their approach. I ploughed ahead with my PowerPoint presentation like a muppet.

The Power of Uncomfortable Pauses

Watch any skilled comedian work a difficult crowd. They're not afraid of silence. They'll let an awkward moment stretch just long enough to become funny in itself. They understand that discomfort often precedes breakthrough.

In business, we're terrified of uncomfortable pauses. Someone's mobile goes off in a meeting, and we all pretend it didn't happen. A suggestion falls flat, and we quickly move on to avoid embarrassment. We're so busy managing everyone's comfort levels that we never push through to the good stuff on the other side.

The most innovative problem-solving training I've ever designed deliberately builds in uncomfortable moments. Moments where teams have to sit with uncertainty, where they can't immediately jump to solutions, where they have to resist the urge to fill every silence with chatter.

Because that's where the magic happens.

When Everything Goes Wrong, Double Down

I watched this comedian at the Brisbane Comedy Festival handle a heckler by making him part of the act. Instead of shutting him down or getting defensive, she started a conversation with him that became funnier than her original material. The whole room was in stitches watching this interaction unfold.

That's advanced-level creative problem solving. When your original plan isn't working, you don't abandon it - you use the failure as material for something better.

The Timing Is Everything Principle

Comedians know that delivery matters as much as content. The same joke can kill or bomb depending entirely on timing. Business teams often get so focused on having the right solution that they completely ignore whether it's the right time for that solution.

I've seen brilliant initiatives fail not because they were wrong, but because they were implemented at precisely the wrong moment in the organisation's lifecycle. A comedian would never tell a divorce joke to a room full of newlyweds, but we routinely pitch efficiency improvements to teams who are already stretched to breaking point.

About 67% of great business solutions fail not because they're bad ideas, but because the timing is off. The other 33% fail because someone tried to implement them like they were reading from a manual instead of adapting to the specific circumstances.

Why Improv Skills Should Be Mandatory in Business School

Improvisational comedy teaches you to say "Yes, and..." instead of "No, but..." It forces you to build on ideas rather than shooting them down. It makes you comfortable with not knowing where you're going until you get there.

These aren't nice-to-have skills in modern business. They're essential.

I've started incorporating improv exercises into my creative problem solving workshops, and the transformation is remarkable. Teams that couldn't agree on lunch suddenly start building on each other's ideas. People who were afraid to speak up in meetings start contributing regularly.

The secret is that improv creates a safe space to be vulnerable and uncertain - two things that are absolutely crucial for innovation but completely absent from most corporate environments.

The Counter-Intuitive Truth About Professional Standards

Here's an unpopular opinion: our obsession with looking professional is killing our ability to solve problems creatively.

Comedians look like complete amateurs when they're developing new material. They stumble, they repeat themselves, they try things that don't work. But they're constantly experimenting, constantly learning, constantly improving.

Business professionals are so worried about appearing competent that we rarely allow ourselves to look foolish, even in private. We present polished solutions that haven't been properly tested instead of messy ideas that might actually work.

The companies that are consistently out-innovating their competitors? They're the ones that have figured out how to maintain high standards while creating space for productive failure.

What Actually Works (According to Someone Who's Seen It All)

After nearly two decades of watching teams struggle with creative problem solving, here's what I've learned actually moves the needle:

Give people permission to be genuinely terrible at something before expecting them to be good at it. Create environments where the dumbest question in the room gets celebrated instead of ignored. Stop treating uncertainty like a problem to be solved immediately.

Most importantly, recognise that creative problem solving isn't a skill you learn once in a workshop. It's a muscle that needs constant exercise. Comedians don't become funny by reading books about comedy. They become funny by getting on stage repeatedly and figuring out what works through trial and error.

Your business problems are the same. Stop looking for perfect solutions and start getting comfortable with perfect iterations.

The comedian who bombed at the start of this story? He's headlining his own show now. Not because he stopped failing, but because he got really good at failing forward.

That's a skill worth developing, whether you're trying to make people laugh or trying to make your quarterly targets.

Looking for more insights on developing creative problem-solving capabilities in your organisation? Check out our problem solving skills training or explore creative workshops designed for Australian business teams.